Few sitcoms in recent history have been as polarizing as The Big Bang Theory. The show, which ran for twelve seasons, amassed a dedicated fanbase and garnered critical acclaim, yet it also faced significant criticism. One recurring point of contention is its use of canned laughter. While many argue that the laughter track is a relic of a bygone television era, for The Big Bang Theory, it is an essential component. Without it, the show often sounds cringey and fails to land its jokes effectively.
Canned laughter, or laugh tracks, have been a staple of television comedy since the 1950s. They serve to cue the audience on when to laugh, creating a communal viewing experience reminiscent of live theater. For The Big Bang Theory, this element is not just a tradition but a necessity.
A notable example can be found in YouTube videos where the laugh track is removed from scenes of The Big Bang Theory. One popular clip features the gang playing Pictionary. In the original scene, Sheldon, played by Jim Parsons, humorously fails to grasp the concept of drawing simple objects, resulting in absurdly complex diagrams. With the laugh track, the audience is invited to share in the joke, appreciating Sheldon's obliviousness and the group's growing frustration. However, without the laugh track, the scene feels painfully awkward. The silence accentuates Sheldon’s social ineptitude, making the situation uncomfortable rather than amusing. The group's reactions, instead of being seen as part of a humorous dynamic, come across as genuine irritation, which changes the tone entirely.
Watch this clip here:
Another example is a scene where the group discusses "Shamy" (Sheldon and Amy's relationship). This scene features rapid exchanges and subtle humor as the friends dissect the peculiarities of Sheldon and Amy’s romantic interactions. With the laugh track, each quip and reaction is punctuated with laughter, helping to maintain a light, comedic atmosphere. The laughter cues the audience to the humor in the characters’ observations and the eccentric nature of Shamy’s relationship. Without the laugh track, the scene becomes stilted and uncomfortable. The humor in their dialogue is lost, and what remains is a series of awkward statements about a couple’s odd relationship, making the characters seem more like they are mocking rather than playfully teasing their friends.
Watch it here:
Critics of canned laughter often argue that it manipulates the audience, forcing them to find something funny that they might not otherwise laugh at. However, in the context of The Big Bang Theory, it is more about maintaining the comedic rhythm and tone. The show’s humor relies heavily on its characters' quirks and rapid-fire dialogue, which can come across as abrasive or flat without the accompanying laughter to soften the delivery.
Moreover, The Big Bang Theory often dives into niche topics, from advanced physics to comic book lore, which might not resonate with all viewers. The laugh track acts as a guide, helping the audience understand when a moment is meant to be funny, even if they do not fully grasp the reference. This universal cue is crucial in maintaining the show's broad appeal.
While canned laughter may seem outdated to some, for The Big Bang Theory, it is an indispensable element. It enhances the comedic timing, softens potentially awkward interactions, and helps guide the audience through the show’s unique brand of humor. The absence of the laugh track leaves scenes feeling flat, cringey, and uncomfortable, underscoring its importance. As evidenced by various YouTube videos, The Big Bang Theory without canned laughter just doesn’t work. It is a testament to how integral this traditional television tool is to the show's success.
